Symphogear Episode 04: Falling Tears

Episode Summary:

We start this episode five years before Tsubasa and Hibiki stare down the mystery girl wearing the Nehushtan armor. 2nd Division has just rescued Kanade Amou from the aftermath of a Noise attack on an artifact dig site. This isn’t the same calm, collected Kanade we first met three years later at the Zwei Wing concert in episode 1. As judged by the straight jacket she is strapped into, this Kanade is enraged to the point that she might even be a danger to herself and others. Through angered shouts and expletives, she makes clear that the only thing she wants is a way to kill the Noise who killed her family. No matter the personal cost to herself. All while a young Tsubasa watches timidly tucked away in her uncle’s shadow.

Genjuro and Ryoko put Kanade through a series of experiments meant to see if she can link with a Relic. While Tsubasa can naturally link with her Ame no Habakiri, it at first it seems like Kanade is unable to do the same. It’s only after Kanade takes matters into her own hands and injects herself with a dangerous overdose of the drugs they were testing on her that she is able to form a bond with Gungnir. In a dramatic scene she coughs up quite a bit of blood but successfully summons her Symphogear in the end.

From then on, Kanade fights for revenge along side Tsubasa. Until, after one battle, some soldiers the two saved note how nice it was to hear Kanade’s singing in the midst of battle. This has a transformative effect on Kanade. Her worldview that only contained thoughts of revenge shifts to one of using her abilities to make people happy which leads to the creation of Zwei Wing.

Back in the present, Tsubasa stares down the mysterious girl in the Nehushtan armor. The two begin a battle, and while they are closely matched, the mystery girl seems to have a small but notable advantage in power. At one point during the battle she pulls out some sort of weapon and fire it at the ground in order to summon Noise! A few of the Noise trap Hibiki while the rest serve as an obstacle for Tsubasa.

The battle looks like it is near its end when Tsubasa is knocked to the ground. The mystery girl taunts her, saying that Tsubasa isn’t even the reason she’s there. Really, she came to capture Hibiki, but she doesn’t say why. In response, Tsubasa vows to defeat the mystery girl before pinning her shadow to the ground with a small dagger. She then make a point of reminding Hibiki just how far she’s willing to go to achieve victory against the Noise and this new opponent.

Then, Tsubasa sings. She puts away her sword and slowly walks towards the mystery girl while singing her Superb Song. Blood flows from her mouth as she looks the frightened mystery girl directly in the eyes. The resulting blast destroys all the nearby Noise and seemingly badly injures the girl as well. The mystery girl flees just before Genjuro and Ryoko arrive. Tsubasa claims to be all right. That, as a sword, she won’t break now… but her claims are obviously a lie as there is a pool of her own blood forming below her all flowing from her mouth and even her eyes. A moment later Tsubasa falls to the ground.

We find out that singing a Superb Song is not necessarily fatal as Tsubasa is apparently rushed to a hospital and the doctors manage to save her life. It seems like she might even be able to fully recover in time. Meanwhile, Hibiki is beating herself up over her role in Tsubasa’s fall. She finally realizes that offering to replace Kanade was the wrong thing to do. Ogawa helps her understand more about Tsubasa and her need to fight after Kanade’s death.

Later we see that Hibiki is still working through the suffering Tsubasa must have been going through since Kanade’s death. First in a meeting with 2nd Division’s leaders, and then on the roof overlooking the hospital where Miku helps encourage her. Finally, after a month or more of trying to be Kanade’s replacement, Hibiki decides to be herself and protect the things she cherishes as herself.

We then get a fantastic training montage as Hibiki trains hard under Genjuro all while Miku watches in secret from the shadows. The episode actually ends on something of an ominous note as Hibiki promises Miku that she’ll never keep a secret from her…

Episode Impressions: 

Although I enjoyed the first three episodes of Symphogear, this is the one that really sold me on the series. Kanade’s destructive determination to kill the monsters that murdered her family was really impactful. But so was her shift to the calm, encouraging Kanade that we knew from the first episode.

Tsubasa’s fight with the mystery girl was impressive. There was some nice choreography in there. Tsubasa’s solution was chilling and had a great buildup.

Afterwards, it was great to see Hibiki really work towards understanding Tsubasa’s thinking and her own role in Tsubasa’s fall. That Hibiki’s solution was to actually train for her role as a Symphogear user for the first time was great to see. There’s a good number of easter eggs in that training montage and it had me laughing out loud.

Specific Scenes I Loved: 

Kanade trying to sync with Gungnir. Her near insanity. Her willingness to risk death for the slim chance at getting her revenge. That bloody hand and handprint as she finally synced up with the relic. Her sheer frightening joy when she completed her first transformation and knew she could finally kill Noise. It was a great scene. Like I said above, it’s the scene that sold me on Symphogear as a show. The writing and emotions there had me convinced the show really knew what it was doing.

Tsubasa’s fight with the mystery girl. The Blue Flash attack being blocked and redirected. Tsubasa’s sword skills being bested. And her comeback with Shadow Weaving and her Superb Song. There was a great flow to the entire battle and also some great tension near the end. The musical buildup to the Superb Song was almost a little frightening. I knew that Tsubasa’s chilling, echoing song was coming, and I knew what singing it had done to Kanade. There was at least a chance Tsubasa might actually die which made it a very impactful scene.

Hibiki’s talk with Ogawa. Especially that moment where Hibiki asks if Kanade died to save her and Ogawa pauses and then takes a sip of his drink instead of answering. Brad Bird once said it about his movie The Incredible, but I think it’s true of every medium: One of the hardest things to do well is just having two people in a room talking about serious things. No jokes. No quips. No fights or explosions. To get points across and keep things interesting requires good writing and good characters. This scene had both. And this scene sets Hibiki and Tsubasa down a path towards a better relationship, which is nice.

Hibiki’s training montage. I probably missed some references, but at the very least it has Hibiki and Genjuro dressed as Bruce Lee. It has them dressed as fighters from Street Fighter, too, among all its silly looking exercises. I loved it!

Songs In This Episode: 

Zettō Ame no Habakiri – This song has the same meaning as before. It’s about Tsubasa grieving for and deriving determination from Kanade’s death. But now, it is directed at someone who might have played a role in that death. So, there’s another little layer of meaning on top of the dark themes already contained within Tsubasa’s iconic song.

Gekisou Gungnir – Hibiki’s song is used as the slow background music for her talk with Ogawa, and then as part of her training montage. A lot of meaning here? Maybe not. But Hibiki’s focus on bridging gaps and looking to the future does fit in with what she is trying to do with Tsubasa.

Themes In This Episode: 

The better world Kanade saw. The first theme we get in this episode comes from Kanade. Her initial, self-destructive rage at what the Noise did to her family and then later her revelation that her songs are useful for more than killing Noise. That they can help and inspire people, as well. I bet we’ll see more on this later, but it’s already pretty clear that Kanade shifted from someone only focused on revenge to a person who discovered a better way of living and was trying to help Tsubasa find that better way as well.

If anything, Tsubasa is sorta in early Kanade’s place right now. We don’t know what her childhood was like except that she was present at 2nd Division even when she was younger. But now, and for the past two years, Tsubasa has been caught up in a slightly more controlled cycle of rage and despair caused by Kanade’s death.

Tsubasa’s self sacrifice. I think we also got a little aspect of self sacrifice from Tsubasa. Was her Superb Song fully necessary? Could she have maybe retreated with Hibiki? Sure, she sang it to defeat the Noise and the mystery girl, but she also sang her Superb Song to make one final point to Hibiki about how Hibiki lacked determination to combat the Noise. It was almost a cruel jab, as if saying: “you’re so weak that I have to sacrifice my life to save yours… just like Kanade did.”

Hibiki finding her purpose. In the second half of the episode, Hibiki is finally able to come to understand both Tsubasa and herself. Ogawa helps her understand Tsubasa’s need to fight, and through that, Hibiki realizes just why it was so wrong to try and directly replace Kanade in Tsubasa’s life. It was never healthy for Tsubasa to channel her anger and sadness into nothing but fighting Noise, but for someone new to come along and try to fill that void without understanding it was only contributing to the problem.

But Hibiki also learned something about herself. She’d already figured it out a bit, that she too had something she wanted to protect. She speaks it directly in this episode. “It might just be a tiny promise or my bland everyday life, but I want to become stronger to protect them and still be myself.” Even if she knew she wanted to use her Symphogear to protect people, Hibiki had not yet really acted to gain the skills necessary to do so. Sure, she was fairly powerful when she went into that little rage at not being able to see the meteor shower with Miku, but she hadn’t even tried training to improve her skills. Finally, she has committed herself to actually learning to wield her Symphogear effectively. I can’t wait to see the results of her training montage.

Finally, let’s think about the episode title: Falling Tears. There were a lot of tears that fell in this episode:

First we need to think about who hadn’t let any tears fall. Both Kanade in her enraged state, and Tsubasa after Kanade’s death refused to shed any tears. Kanade was in a mad rage for a long time. Tsubasa’s rage and despair was more channeled or maybe more controlled, but she too didn’t cry for almost two years after Kanade’s death.

Next we have Tsubasa’s tears of blood flowing from her eyes after she sings her Superb Song. Her final statement before she collapses is her declaration of her current way of living. That she is a sword dedicated to defending people and that she will not break… which she must know is a lie. There’s blood flowing from her mouth and eyes and pooling at her feet. Maybe she is letting tears fall for herself, knowing that she has failed even in her desperate role of self sacrifice?

Then there’s Hibiki’s tears as she finally grasps the realization of Tsubasa’s cruel fate. Hibiki feels bad about what she’s done and at her lack of understanding. But, she isn’t crying for herself, rather she is crying at the tragic situation Tsubasa has been forced to live with the past few years.

Hibiki also sheds tears of joy as she and Miku share a moment of friendship on the roof. These kind of tears are important, too! Not all tears come from sadness and despair.

There’s one last instance of tears that’s a bit more subtle because its heard rather than seen. Hibiki’s Symphogear song, Gekisou Gungnir, includes a line that says something like: “I have no time to shed tears, I have things I want to protect” Unlike Tsubasa’s song, Hibiki’s has never been about channeling rage and despair. It’s always been an uplifting song of looking to the future and helping others. Tsubasa and Kanade refused to shed tears because to do so would be to show weakness or admit their sadness. We’ve seen Hibiki cry plenty, but the times she refuses to cry aren’t because she is holding in her sadness, but because she’s putting it aside to help others. Hibiki has been free to cry when she’s needed to while Kanade and Tsubasa weren’t. It’s an interesting distinction.

Special Attacks In This Episode: